Throughout the semester we have had a lot of interesting topics. All the people in class have different perspectives and views of how their favorite television shows and movies play a role throughout the media.
For my last and final blog as an undergrad, our media criticism class is taking a different approach. Instead of interpreting media through the terminology taught in class, I will be reading four of my classmate’s blogs and commenting on them. I will discuss what I enjoyed about their blog as well as what I learned and why I believe it is important to know. I also will be explaining what I know about the topic and what they didn’t cover.
I will be providing additional information, examples and sources to support their discussions and why I believe it would be important to implement in their discussions. If there is a point that I disagree with I will explain my beliefs and thoughts about their discussion. Most importantly I will be adding my input of what they can improve upon.
I think this is a great way of giving feedback. In addition, I believe that you can learn a lot by how and what people say towards a particular topic. I am really excited to find interesting information that will broaden my horizon and encourage me to watch new shows and movies.
I chose to read Ben Cooper’s blog about Betty White! I absolutely love her and loved every time that commercial would air on television. I thought you had really interesting things to say about how it related to the Super Bowl.
The way you introduced your ideas really made me think. When you talked about ageism and said that the elderly were childlike grabbed my attention. When I go out to the mall or something I always see the cutest little old lady or man and I just say something to myself. But normally most people don’t think about them like children.
Majority of commercials are misleading and do not work once you finally go to the store to buy them. With Snickers they are filling! If I am starving and don’t have much time to eat I get a Snickers and eat it before class or between lunch and dinner. I definitely didn’t think about the guy who was playing football that turned into Betty White was an insult.
It is interesting to see the commercial now after you say that. I thought it was referring to like you haven’t prepared enough like lack of sleep or not exercising enough was related to feeling like an old person. Probably the number one thing I don’t like on your blog is the picture of that terrible football player. I mean come on now, what about them RAVENS!
After Ben’s blog, I went through and picked Amy’s blog about Raising Hope. I can’t believe there would even be a show with that crazy of a plot line and it’s hilarious? You really caught my attention and I hope that after school is over I can watch the episodes that were previously aired. That is ridiculous that Jimmy’s mother was telling him to give away his son. How could a mother say that?
I thought it was really funny how the mom reacted in the video to Hope. I think Jimmy is brave and he will survive through all of his hardships to come. I felt like as soon as Jimmy’s mother started singing she had a connection to her like she did with Jimmy.
You used a great approach to criticism; Raising Hope is a chain of events and happenings that explain how his life is going due to this new responsibility in his life and what the future holds. Raising Hope is supposedly hilarious, so the scenes that the director chooses to form the plot based on the underlying story seems like a hard job.
The only thing I would suggest on changing is by making smaller paragraphs so that it is easier to follow throughout your blog. What a great job, I can’t wait to watch the series! Thanks for the recommendation!
Erin’s blog called, “You’re selling…jeans?” caught my eye. I believe that people in America are very materialistic and this is a representation of it. I thought it was great how you introduced how Calvin Klein advertisements feature celebrities in little or no clothing, which brings out the sex appeal.
Sex does sell. Even though some people think it is provocative, everyone wants to look sexy and feel good about them. If these advertisements show that they are “living the life” and they have the materialistic things in life then they will be happier.
I think it is good that American television banned these commercial advertisements from airing to viewers. We talked a lot in class about the “Tween” and I feel like they will start to act like that and be portrayed in that kind of light. You chose a great approach to relate semiotics to Calvin Klein advertisements.
I think it is interesting how some times you can’t tell what the advertisement’s main focus is; whether it be sex or selling certain products to the media. I never noticed how it appears that the girls in the advertisement are under control of the men, relating it to ideological criticism. That is funny you said that the guy laying on the floor had already gotten his turn with the girl which could then lead to what were they doing right before it was shot.
For the final comment, I have chosen Charlie’s blog about Dexter. I love that other people in the class were just as into it as I am. I definitely agree with you that the word criticism should not always be taken negatively. I was scarred from last semester in Rhetorical Theory and Criticism that any time of criticism I had a negative outlook on. After taking this class though I really enjoyed criticizing media text and talking about it through our blogs and in class discussion.
I thought it was interesting how you used Vladamir Propp’s eight character types to create a better understanding for those who do not watch the series. It’s interesting how Dexter can be considered the hero and the villain at the same time. Depending on how you interpret his ambiguous messages is how you could perceive him.
I would have definitely considered the “Ice Truck Killer” to be the villain instead of the false hero. The ways people are perceived are not how they are in real life. Everyone puts on a front and it is really cool to see how he or she develops through each episode and then into the next season.
You brought up some interesting points that I never really thought about, like that Laura Moser; Dexter’s biological mother is the dispatcher. She was a confidential informant for Harry Morgan who is eventually Dexter’s adoptive father. I wish you had embedded some pictures or links to the show or even put a YouTube clip in to attract your viewers!
Reading my classmates blogs really helped me see a different side of things and have learned a lot from their comments. Even though this is the last blog I hope to continue writing on Word Press to express my ideas. I feel like it also brought us together, relating our ideas with one another and expanding upon them.





























